Banning Ibiza after parties

It's the big topic of conversation amongst the people headed for Ibiza's clubs this summer. I'm not convinced that it's such a big deal.

The plan by the authorities is to stop clubs and 'music bars' opening before 4.30pm. It's actually not quite that straightforward as San An's mayor in particular has noticed that a blanket ban would prevent bars from showing some of the Euro 2008 games. So the impact of the ban differs according to which town council's in charge.

What all the councils agree is that they want to stop the 24-hour clubbing phenomenon. So there should be a break from 6am until 4.30pm. Or so they say. DC10 seems to be ignoring the ban and planning to open at 8am as ever. Space has a dispensation, it seems, to open at noon for its opening party. Apart from those you shouldn't find any public daytime parties this summer. We'll see.

The argument the politicians put forward is that nobody can keep going for 24 hours without drugs. They have a point. Maybe there are a few people who can go straight from Space to DC10 sustained by nothing stronger than Red Bull and electronica, but I haven't met many.

Recreational drugs are, of course, no more legal in Ibiza than they are in the rest of Spain, or most of the world for that matter. So the authorities have a duty to try and prevent their sale, possession and consumption. They argue that the lengthy enforced break will cut drug use.

"Nonsense" - or words to that effect - respond many of the clubbers and promoters I've spoken to. In the absense of an organised after-party people will just head for villas, apartments, hotel rooms or beaches to carry on. The effect will be to annoy everybody who doesn't want to share their peace and quiet with groups of caned clubbers. It's also considerably more dangerous to overdo it in private than in a well-supervised club.

There's some truth in the argument that the new law will just scatter the caners. But there's another side to the argument. Part of the point of heading to an after-party is to score more gear. There are always dealers in and around after-hours venues. Close them and people will have nowhere to go and replenish their stocks. Without anywhere to go some people who would have carried on partying will head off for a sleep.

Of course, as long as there are bars, cafes and shops open, there'll be places to score and people to sell. News travels pretty fast on the Ibiza grapevine. That doesn't mean the information will get through to every would-be drug user on the island. Many will be scared to ask around about buying drugs. And they're not stupid. Getting busted is not the ideal way to extend your holiday.

My feeling is that the authorities may be right and the new closing hours will cut drug consumption. But I don't think it'll have a huge impact. The price that will be paid for that slight reduction will be an increase in nuisance for holidaymakers and residents. Instead of being in clubs and bars the noisy caners will be on your beach, in the hotel room next to you or throwing up over the balcony of the apartment above you. (I should say I'm certainly not having a go at everybody who likes to party, but there's enough of a minority to piss off a lot of people.)

I also think the big changes in club hours have already happened without much fuss. As soon as the authorities started to enforce 6am closing at the big clubs they created a two-hour break before Space, DC10 etc opened. And most of the people who've complained most loudly to me about the ban on opening before 4.30pm never hit the terraces before then anyway.

Don't worry it'll still be a great summer. Ibiza's culture flourishes in the face of a little adversity.


Technorati Tags space,nick,drugs,ibiza,clayton,dc10,parties